This video, that my sister brought to my attention, has a lot of food for thought… http://www.ted.com/talks/brene_brown_on_vulnerability.html. I think that being comfortable with vulnerability comes from self-confidence, and that self-confidence just is (or isn’t). Self-confidence doesn’t come from anything. It is either there, in you, or not. In one case, you’re very fortunate, as you will be comfortable with vulnerability and will therefore connect more with people. In the other case, you’re rather unfortunate, as you will be afraid of taking risks, and will not connect with people as much, and will feel somewhat isolated.
Which one am I? Which one are you? In fact probably a bit of both: it’s really the relative proportion of the two that determine how “wholehearted” one is. The larger the percentage of your personality which has the “self-confident” flag, the more “wholehearted” you are. I don’t see myself as a wholehearted person, though I would certainly like to be. Brown’s talk suggests that we would all gain a lot from becoming (more) comfortable with being more vulnerable… but if this relies upon self-confidence, then you can’t just “will” yourself to be more vulnerable. Might work for a while but the discomfort will pull you back to your old habits.
Unless… self-confidence is “learnt” by taking risks and learning from the mistakes, and feeling good about the successes and the lessons learnt. In other words, self-confidence gets built by being vulnerable. Once more a chicken and egg problem. Wait, maybe not: what if you start by being vulnerable, despite the discomfort, and what you need is the “attitude”: think positive. Then the positive attitude (learn and cheer) around your failures and successes will build your self-confidence, which will make your more comfortable with being vulnerable, which will make you more connected to people, which will make you happier, which will make you more self-confident, and so on.
So the real question is then: where does that positive attitude come from? It is crucial because from it may affect self-confidence, comfort with vulnerability, connection, and therefore happiness. It may well be religious or spiritual: positive attitude is a “belief”, a lot like the belief in God. You just “believe” you can beat the odds, that you have a chance. You have some logical reasons to support that belief, but most of the belief is just that, a belief, a conviction. I suppose that every time the belief gets tested, it either gets degraded, or re-enforced. Eventually you end up with a negative attitude or a very positive attitude.
In which case it is really about judgement. You are faced with all sorts of situations, you must judge your likelyhood of success, you have a certain attitude, and your attitude will affect your chance of success, and the success will affect your ego, ie it will “correct” your attitude. So someone faced with very difficult situations at a young age, with nothing to go by for judging chances at success, would likely end up with fairly negative attitude, cynicism… but if they were lucky, the situations would turn out very positive, and even though they hadn’t had good judgement, the fact that they were lucky (without them knowing) means their attitude became very positive, which made them comfortable taking more risk. And at that point if they didn’t have good judgement you would think that they would make mistakes and end up with a negative attitude, because luck always runs out.
So “judgement”, that intuition you have about your environment, how it works, how people think, about outcomes… perhaps that is what affects, ultimately, your happiness. And if THAT is the case well, you still have a chance because judgement can be improved, by learning. So as long as you can learn, you can improve your judgement, you can make better choices, afford to take more risk, be comfortable with that vulnerability, connect more with people, and be happier in life. Once you can no longer learn, you will quickly isolate yourself.
This is rather encouraging. Except that we all learn different things with different ease. Maybe there are some things that my brain just can’t learn. For those things, I can never build confidence, and for those things, and can never connect to those who are comfortable with vulnerability in that domain. But at least now there is something to try for. A path. Discover those things that scare you and learn as much about everything related so that you can improve your judgement about them etc. Do this for a few of your personality traits and you will likely become a strong, more connected, happier person.
Well, sounds plausible anyways. It would be nice to hear what others have to say.